Napanee arson case enters new phase

Get set for sentencing

On Friday, November 1, 2024, the Napanee courthouse witnessed powerful victim impact statements and closing arguments in the case against Jay Bradley, charged with arson and criminal harassment. Bradley’s sentencing is scheduled for November 8, when Justice Geoffrey Griffin will review the emotional statements and final arguments presented.

Bradley pleaded guilty to setting fires on October 23, 2023, that destroyed the Lennox Agricultural Memorial Community Centre and damaged the garage of Carol McKinley, the Lennox Agricultural Society president.

McKinley and her family, directly targeted in the attack, spoke in court, describing ongoing trauma, financial loss, and a lingering fear for their safety. They were not alone in their distress. Several community groups, such as the Napanee Sea Cadets, also suffered significant losses. The Sea Cadets estimated over $70,000 worth of damage to uniforms, equipment, and cherished memorabilia, resulting in reduced membership and fewer training opportunities. Other groups, including the Pickleball Club, shared the profound impact of losing their community space, describing it as a place that fostered friendship and well-being.

Bradley expressed remorse, saying he was grateful that no one was injured. However, Justice Griffin emphasized the deep community impact, noting that the arena was a cherished space with historical value and calling Bradley’s actions a “terrible, evil act.”

Crown attorney Kerry Watson requested a five-year sentence with 546 days reduced for time already served, while Bradley’s defense lawyer, Jason Dickson, proposed three years, with one year deducted. Bradley also faces a $3.5 million restitution requested by Watson, though he has limited assets; his car, a 1953 Pontiac STR, which was used in the crime, may be auctioned to aid victims.